『#シャッターアイランド』そもそも論 テディ（ディカプリオ）はなぜこの島に来たのか？（独自解説 ）
How is everyone? This is Suguwa This time, I thought I’d think about Shutter Island Shutter Island was released in 2010 Directed by Martin Scorsese Written by Laeta Kalogridis This movie is based on the novel Shutter Island by Dennis Lehane Actually, this is the first video I’ve ever made that was directed by Scorsese I’ve done reviews of new releases before I previously introduced Killers of the Flower Moon This was actually the first time I did an original commentary on a film directed by Scorsese That’s surprising It’s not that I was avoiding it By chance This Shutter Island I saw it back then too, but it’s a movie that everyone knows they have to watch twice It’s a complete first-time killer movie Everyone will definitely watch the movie twice It’s a movie that, after watching it twice, you understand it and don’t want to watch it any more Once everyone has watched it once, they’ll watch it a second time Amazing! Apparently there were two viewing campaigns at the time You can still see the campaign website I saw that site and I thought Before Scorsese was chosen to direct the film, David Andrew Leo Fincher was apparently in the running to direct it This movie was released in 2010, after Fincher had already shot Seven, Seven, and Fight Club I understand why David Andrew Leo Fincher is directing Shutter Island Shutter Island is very David Andrew Leo Fincher-esque, but I think it also has a lot in common with Fight Club Shutter Island has a similar feel to previous games like Seven and Fight Club I think director David Andrew Leo Fincher is good at it It seems like the kind of thing director David Andrew Leo Fincher is good at Maybe it’s not so good I think Scorsese might be better However, I think the atmosphere would have been a little different if director David Andrew Leo Fincher had filmed it This movie has no original music All songs are pre-made The last line that DiCaprio says is not in the original novel but is original to the movie There are many opinions around the world about that last line What is this? What does it mean? Or what does it mean like this? There are various things Shutter Island I haven’t covered it yet because I didn’t think there was much to talk about I got a lot of requests for this movie, but what can I say? On my channel, Shutter Island is a bit of a common movie, or a compulsory education movie So it feels like the only people watching my channel are those who are fully aware of everything about Shutter Island So here’s what people are saying I feel like even if I say a lot of things, I was wondering, what should I do? The title of this video is “Let’s follow Teddy’s delusions!” This video will focus on Teddy’s delusions Everyone often watches The theory and explanation of Shutter Island is that in Teddy’s dream, there was a fire scene and that’s why there was so much water There are many other popular items as well I chose this video because I wanted to explain this movie from a slightly different angle So today I’ll be talking about Shutter Island Thank you very much I will explain the basic parts of this work I think everyone understands that DiCaprio plays Sheriff Teddy Daniels In fact, Teddy is the same person as former sheriff Andrew Reddy Sheriff Teddy Daniels is the main character in the play Former Sheriff Andrew Reddy is a past protagonist So the real personality is Andrew Ladies In the film, the alter ego Teddy Daniels comes to the forefront What is Teddy doing? He believes he’s here to investigate the disappearance of Rachel Solander from Ashecliffe Psychiatric Hospital However, his real identity, Andrew Reddy, is a patient at Ashecliffe Psychiatric Hospital and is considered dangerous The story was about the delusions of a former sheriff’s lady The disappearance of Rachel Solando by her second personality, Teddy In reality, the hospital recreates Teddy’s fantasy The hospital staff conducted role-play therapy aimed at helping him re-enact his delusions, accept his past mistakes, and regain his dominant identity, Andrew Ladies The audience is so surprised to find out this at the end that they all end up watching the movie again So the delusions and dreams of the protagonist Teddy in the play are equal to a distorted version of the truth This is where the story gets really interesting I think if you watch this part to the end, you will understand it and everyone will find it interesting In other words, in this story, Teddy, who has a different personality, appears as the protagonist Teddy is an alternate personality that Lady’s original personality created because she couldn’t accept reality Teddy’s past is a fabrication of the painful events he actually experienced, but it was fabricated by altering the memories of the ladies’ past with delusions and dreams These three points make the story interesting This work is a plot by the director of Ashcliffe Psychiatric Hospital It depicts the most extensive medical treatment ever undertaken Doing that much for one patient? That’s the kind of feeling it has, but that’s the kind of movie it is The reason why the director of Ashcliffe Psychiatric Hospital is doing this is revealed in the final lines of the story By Andrew, I mean Andrew Ladies “If Andrew’s fantasy is realized, he will surely regain his sanity The more I act, the more I come across the contradictions within myself and the more I regain my sanity, which is why I did it this time.” “We all put on a big play,” said the director This is the purpose of the doctor’s treatment The director’s aim is that by realizing the delusion, the patient will come to terms with the contradiction and regain their senses Now, what is the director’s goal? I will examine whether the idea of regaining sanity when confronted with a contradiction works That’s the purpose of this video So in this video, I’m basically going to piece together Teddy’s past and Teddy’s dreams and see if there are any contradictions Let’s talk about Teddy’s past There are a lot of contradictions in the opening, and things that are strange This is the cinematic trick I won’t be talking much about how this is, or anything like that this time I feel like everyone is probably sick of hearing about that If you want to know more about that, I think you can probably find it on other sites So let’s take a look at Teddy’s past This is the scene where Teddy is on the ship talking to his subordinate Chuck and remembering his past “What about your family?” asks Chuck Teddy is remembering the past The scene where he receives a flashy tie from Dolores Dolores is barefoot in this scene And the scene where the record is playing A sudden cut to footage of the ocean and waves And then the past, Dolores’ smile, comes to mind Here Teddy says: “My wife died. Four people died in an apartment fire while I was at work “The good news is that it was smoke, not fire,” Teddy said, looking back on the past This Teddy Bear photo is one of the few memories I have of Teddy Bear In fact, there are surprisingly few memories of Teddy’s past It’s still early in the movie There’s not much information here, but I’m basically just reminiscing on some fun memories with my wife, Dolores But being on a boat suddenly brings to mind images of waves The associations that come to Teddy’s mind are boat = sea = waves = water = lake = drowning There is a movie called “Paprika” Animated film directed by Satoshi Kon, based on the original work by Yasutaka Tsutsui The movie “Paprika” is a masterpiece, but this is often mentioned in “Paprika” For example, “Doraemon” sometimes has this problem Dreams and delusions are associations of the past Overall, Teddy’s dreams, past and delusions are all basically made up of lies The lie is created by association This appears in dream interpretation, dream interpretation, and dream diagnosis by Freud and Jung It is also commonly used in psychology I think this association is becoming a very important point In this wave scene, for example, waves = water = boat =… and so on This shows that it is the bad memories of the ladies, not Teddy, that come to mind by association So, I’ll give you a rundown of the events that required Sheriff Teddy Daniels to show up Rachel Solander, a patient at Ashcliffe Psychiatric Hospital on a remote island at sea, escaped last night between 10am and midnight She disappeared She was put here for murdering her three children and drowning them in the lake behind her house It’s a woman Her husband is believed to have been killed in action during the Normandy landings The Normandy landings took place in June 1944 For more information, see The Biggest Operation in History He is said to have died in action while taking part in the Normandy landings She, Rachel Solander, thinks of the hospital as her home and the staff and other people as her neighbors The woman who claims her child is still alive is Rachel Solander When she disappeared, Teddy came to investigate Her shoes were left in the room So it is assumed that she is currently barefoot It is believed that he wanders around the island barefoot And Teddy finds a note under the floorboards between the wall and the bed I think it’s strange to pinpoint a place like this Of course, Teddy knew there was a note there, but he pretended not to know and just found the note there The note read: The note read, “The Rule of 4: Who is 67?” What on earth is this? This is the key to the case Maybe it’s a hint of some kind? Since she went missing They searched the whole island but he is nowhere to be found This is also where we are searching Staff members have been called in to act as a sort of search team, but no one is taking the search seriously This is also a movie trick That’s how it’s depicted in an interesting way It’s a play, after all It shows that no one is seriously investigating the case Ah! Here is something like this It would be interesting to find out in the second or third week They searched the whole island, but they couldn’t find him anywhere But this is an isolated island and escape is impossible Even if they were to swim out to sea, the tide would bring them back to the island He will definitely reach this island even if he is dead And yet Rachel Solander is nowhere to be found Where did she disappear to? Search for her! That’s the gist of the incident So, when I was listening to the explanation of the incident, I remembered Teddy’s past I think we should take a look at this Overall, the image looks something like this It comes out one after another Basically, this is Teddy’s past two This is a reminder of Teddy’s participation in the Dachau massacre that took place on April 29, 1945 There’s a person lying in the director’s office covered in blood It’s the very first picture This is said to be Nazi SS Lieutenant Heinrich Wicker He’s a lieutenant in the Guard The reason why he is lying on the floor covered in blood is because he was lynched by American soldiers Looking down on this SS lieutenant There is a man named Teddy in the picture, and he was the one who was lynched Incidentally, SS Lieutenant Heinrich Wicker is said to have been lynched and then shot It’s a real person Then the massacre happens American troops massacre German soldiers at the Dachau concentration camp Looking back on this, Teddy has said that it was murder I am saying that I committed genocide, not war This Teddy’s Past 2 is footage of Dachau Teddy’s past 2 is a flashback because the background of the missing person, Rachel Solander, is very similar to that of Lady Gaga’s wife, Dolores Leeds’ wife, Dolores, killed three of their children That’s exactly the same situation as Rachel Solander Of course, that’s how it is Rachel Solander and Lady’s wife Dolores both killed their children in the same situation But the person who’s here now is Teddy Daniels, not Andrew Reddy The murder of an infant by Andrew Leeds or Teddy Daniels’ wife Dolores is a secret that Leeds has kept deep in his heart So it’s a repressed memory I have completely sealed those memories deep in my heart and I try not to let them come out They are repressed memories that have been sealed away Do you understand? It’s scary because it’s a really painful memory Ladys has buried deep in his psyche the memory of his wife killing his child that’s why The horrific scenes at the Dachau concentration camp It has now come to the forefront as a substitute for the memory of his wife killing his child You see, Andrew Reddy has buried deep in his heart the memory of his wife killing his child Teddy Daniels, who is now appearing in the public eye as a substitute for Andrew Ladies, is Teddy… well, let me explain Andrew Laeddis is the main personality and Teddy Daniels is the other personality Is this okay? It’s a case of multiple personalities, dissociative identity disorder Please think of it this way Why did Teddy Daniels appear? The reason this character was created was because Andrew Reddy had suffered so much that it broke his heart Andrew Reddy’s heart is broken and his mind is shattered In order to protect the mind and body of Andrew Reddy, whose mind had collapsed, another personality called Teddy Daniels was born Teddy Daniels is So this new personality was created to protect Andrew Ladies So Teddy Daniels I defend Andrew Ladies 100% That’s why Teddy is the personality that emerged Teddy Daniels is going to protect Andrew Ladies no matter what Rachel Solander’s past history is that her wife murdered her child She looks a lot like Andrew Reddy’s wife So that memory is likely to be recalled But when those memories were remembered, it would destroy Andrew, so Teddy overwrote those memories that would destroy Andrew, and he remembered the horrific scene at Dachau Both are the same memory, but which one is the lighter memory? The massacre at the Dachau concentration camp So the memories of the lynching and massacre you participated in are better than that? So when Teddy heard Rachel Solander’s story, he was reminded of the Dachau massacre So you’re saying not to associate Rachel Solando with his wife Dolores? The memories of the Dachau concentration camp are very thanatos-like, or death drive-like, Memories of wanting to die and death coming to the forefront are what emerge as memories of the Dachau concentration camp Basically, there is this impulsive consciousness This instinctive, impulsive awareness of death has always been there Inside Teddy, he is constantly tormented by this death drive Why does he want to die? Why are the thoughts of death constantly lingering in Teddy’s mind? Because that’s what the main character, Andrew Reddy, wants But Andrew Ladies wants to die, but Teddy came out to keep Andrew Ladies from dying Teddy Daniels is like the guardian deity for Andrew Ladies Teddy appears entirely to protect Andrew, so this impulsive awareness of death The stories keep popping up in Teddy’s head But Teddy keeps trying to shake it off and ends up being tormented all the time So Teddy really, really wants to protect Andrew Ladies Teddy is trying to make sure that he doesn’t die Teddy would do anything for the ladies I would like you to understand that Now, the next dream is about Teddy There was an empty bottle I have dreams where I’m being criticized for drinking and various scenes start to come to mind, or rather overlap Well, this was the first dream, but more and more I began to feel like I didn’t really understand the situation And when you think about it later, you see scenes where water comes out even though there’s a fire, and the audience goes, “Oh!” Let’s look at each one His wife gets angry and says, “There were a lot of empty bottles,” and, “We killed a lot of people in the war,” and, “So you’re going to drink them?” My wife blames me for drinking Speaking of Teddy, what was the reason he started to become an alcoholic? In reality, he was turning to alcohol because he couldn’t bear Dolores’ depression and her tendency to commit suicide This is a story about a lady, not Teddy, but something like that happened But Andrew Ladies loves his wife very much My wife, whom I truly loved, killed my child So that’s why my mind was broken The ladies don’t want to portray Dolores as the bad guy So Teddy is here to protect the ladies So he doesn’t blame Dolores for his drinking So what will they do? War I’m actually drinking because of Dolores, but I can’t tell her that So he is using the phrase “I can’t help but drink alcohol because I killed so many people in the war.” So the reason why memories of Dachau and things like that come up is not because the memories of Dachau are painful, but because So Dachau appears in order to overwrite the image of his wife, Dolores So all of a sudden it’s like, “Was she here?” “No, but she was there.” “Who’s she? Was it Rachel?” Dolores is talking about Rachel I’m not sure who she is referring to Maybe they’re talking about the missing person, Rachel Solander Maybe her daughter, Rachel… probably her third daughter Andrew Ladies loved him Rachel: Maybe he’s talking about her, I don’t know which But at the same time It is unclear which Rachel Teddy is looking for So Teddy is searching now They are searching for Rachel, but it is Teddy who is searching for Rachel You could also say that Teddy’s real personality, Andrew Reddy, is searching for her Daughter Rachel or Rachel Solando My daughters Rachel and Rachel Solander are similar, but they are both searching for In the sense of what you’re after This is a word association game, so it’s all Looking for = Rachel = Rachel Solando That’s how it’s going to turn out Here, the word Rachel If you look at it alone, When we say “Later Solander,” we are referring to a missing person, but when we say “Rachel”… I don’t know if he’s talking about the missing person or his daughter Rather than not knowing which one he was talking about, I’d say he was talking about both I think it’s okay to think of it that way If you do that, the next thing you hear is a conversation like, “Do you remember the house by the lake? We were happy there.” From that point on, Dolores’ personality seemed to change So you say, “She’s here, so don’t go,” and Teddy responds, “I’m not going anywhere.” Looking at the flow of this story, it seems like the girlfriend Dolores is talking about is her daughter Rachel She’s here, dead at the lake house, dead at the lake I feel like that’s what he’s saying In fact, there is no such person as Rachel Solander It’s difficult to know what to think about this Teddy So you’ve buried deep in your heart the fact that Dolores murdered your three children Teddy, or rather Andrew Ladies, has it buried deep in his heart It has become a central part of my life You have three children Three dead children Especially the youngest daughter, Rachel So you are worried about the whereabouts of your three children Teddy is aware that she is dead and is concerned about her whereabouts However, Teddy’s main personality is a lady Andrew Reddy So Andrew Reddy doesn’t want to admit that his wife killed his three children I don’t want to know, or rather I don’t want to believe That’s what happened, that’s what the trauma was, that the mental breakdown was what happened, and that’s where Teddy was born So that’s what Teddy is traumatized by as well There is a part of me that doesn’t want to accept that my daughter is dead Dolores’ actions The reason why Dolores behaves and talks in this way is because she believes that she is a character that the ladies are creating Either way, this is a dream or delusion, so it’s all Ladies or Teddy’s doing A statue of Dolores appears and starts talking Dolores is talking All of this is being said by Teddy or the ladies Dolores is speaking on his behalf, but of course, it’s a dream But Teddy… It’s a personality that exists to ensure that ladies don’t fall apart I’m talking about someone named Rachel They are trying to recognize her as a missing person, not as their daughter Teddy is In reality, the person named Rachel is referring to her daughter Do you understand? For Andrew Reddy, Rachel is a word that refers to his daughter, but she is a different personality A separate personality born to protect the ladies Teddy is trying to identify it as Rachel, the missing person Here, deep inside, there is a great deal of conflict going on between Lady and Teddy So that’s what’s appearing in your dreams After this, water started coming out of Dolores’ stomach, but before you know it, the water had turned into blood Says the line, “I’m a bone in a coffin” Ashes falling all over the room Water overflows from my hands But the room is on fire So, you wake up with a “Ahhh!” and realize it was just a dream In this case, the memories of the ladies appear in the dream Not only the water, but also the blood coming out of my stomach It’s a memory of when Lady shot his wife, Dolores Fire and water, too So overall, memories of the ladies are coming out But this is Teddy’s dream I think that this is where Teddy is a little confused and doesn’t really understand what’s going on So, So there are two types of ladies’ items The same goes for Rachel There are two of everything The ladies are the main characters of the protagonist, Teddy Daniels A person with a real personality That’s Andrew Reddy So there is another lady What that is is explained here He said something like, “This is the mountain I’ve been chasing for many years.” This is Teddy’s line “This is the mountain I’ve been chasing for years When I heard about this case, I volunteered to be in charge Andrew Reddy was the repairman for our apartment He was an arsonist He set our apartment on fire and his wife died in the fire The ladies fled and disappeared But a year later, his papers came through A big scar from his temple to his lip Both eyes are different colors, once you see them you won’t forget He set the school on fire and killed two people Apparently he heard a voice saying “Yare!” I went to prison, but I was transferred here But now it’s gone, there are no records If you’re here, you’re in Building C Even if he dies, his body can be easily hidden here.” Teddy says this is for the ladies Andrew Reddy is a man with a face that you never forget once you see it, a tear in his eye from his mouth to his temple, and different colored eyes, making it hard to imagine that such a person could exist So Teddy is framing Lady as the one who killed his family By doing so, they are trying to distance themselves from the memory of the real ladies Because real ladies have suffered too much If ladies were to appear, If Lady was to come out into the open after replacing Teddy, she might even commit suicide immediately The ladies’ spirit is already broken Ladies think that there is no happiness in this world for them anymore They think the world is ending so much that it makes them mentally collapse If Teddy and Lady’s personalities were to switch, Lady might attempt suicide at that point I just hope I die alone Maybe I’ll die and take a lot of people with me So there is that kind of danger Ladies are really dangerous people I’m already giving up He is a person who believes the world is ending, so you never know what he might do I wish I could just kill myself Because it might not be the case So Teddy is out in public to protect those ladies Well, it’s about dissociative identity disorder/multiple personalities If you’re interested in learning more, I would like you to read “24 Billy Milligans” and its sequel “Billy Milligan and the 23 Coffins” It’s interesting This is a non-fiction work written by Daniel Keyes, who is famous for Flowers for Algernon Please read it Basically, multiple personalities Dissociative identity disorder/multiple personalities They all come out to help their original identities As I’ve said many times before, the reason why the alter-ego Teddy Daniels was created for Andrew Ladies is To help Andrew Reddy So that Andrew Reddy doesn’t die Teddy Daniels was created to prevent Andrew Reddy from hurting other people, and he now appears as a persona So here it is ladies’ There’s no record when we’re talking about these criminal ladies Even if he dies, we can hide his body here I’m saying something like this, but Teddy Daniels is purposefully emphasizing that he will never come face to face with a murderer named Andrew Reddy This is how you try to make yourself feel safe Andrew Reddy is a man who will never be seen again The only person in the world is Teddy Daniels Teddy Daniels’ main character I had to remind myself that Andrew Ladies doesn’t exist It’s okay, it’s okay I think it’s okay to think of it as him trying to gain a sense of security by saying, “Because I’m here, I won’t die.” Teddy was coming here There is an episode where they investigated it What is happening according to Teddy’s research? This is explained here in this hospital I think I should take a moment to look back on it Ashecliffe Psychiatric Hospital is funded by anti-communist groups In other words, what is being said is that funds from liberal anti-communist groups are flowing to this hospital in order to eradicate communism “We’re conducting experiments on mind manipulation here.” Just in case There was something called the Red Scare in America This happened between 1948 and 1950, and it still happens today Communism has no place in America It’s a matter of philosophy, so that’s how it is Well, at that time There was a time when communism was popular in Italy and the Soviet Union There was a student named George Noyce He was a socialist He was a communist, but he worked part-time as a guinea pig for psychology experiments Here at the hospital Then George Noyce started having hallucinations about dragons, nearly killed the professor, and was sent to Block C here So, he was released from the hospital after a year and then two weeks later he killed three people He said in court: “Send me to the electric chair I don’t want to go back to the hospital.” He ended up getting a life sentence I went to meet him I met George Noyce and he was in a terrible state And he made it very clear that human experiments were being carried out here I said I would get evidence, expose them, and crush them This is supposed to be Teddy’s second goal Teddy’s Purpose So what is Teddy doing at the hospital? First of all, I’m here because of the Rachel Solander incident This Rachel Solander case In fact, Teddy So the Rachel Solander incident was just an excuse to come here Their real goal is to track down an arsonist named Andrew Reddy But since there are no records, it’s difficult to track them down Another purpose was to gather evidence that George Noyce had been subjected to human experimentation So those were the two reasons Teddy came here The Rachel Solander incident was a pretext The reason why these are the objectives is that atrocities similar to the Dachau massacre are still occurring on this island in America It’s taking place at Ashcliff Psychiatric Hospital on Shutter Island So I had a journalistic spirit of exposing it Teddy said he was coming here That is what it means And so, just like that, Rachel Solander was discovered This is a fake Rachel Solander In reality, this person is a nurse The hospital’s aim was to bring about some kind of change in Teddy or Lady Gaga by having Teddy meet Rachel Solando, who was in a very similar situation to Dolores In other words, Teddy has been having these kinds of delusions all this time The usual Teddy or Lady fantasy is So this is where it ends and we’re just going around in circles So as a hospital Teddy Ladies’ actions up to this point were within expectations From here on, it’s an unknown world Because I had never acted before It’s a theatrical treatment I had never done this role-play therapy before Naturally, Teddy comes face to face with Rachel Solander So that means it’s something that hasn’t happened before So we decided to give it a try So from this point on, it’s all unknown territory for the hospital Now that Rachel Solander has been found, what action will Teddy take? This is a very important question for the hospital By the way, here is a new character A guard captain named Voden appears in the film He is Buffalo Bill, the perpetrator in “Silence of the Lambs.” This is a bit of trivia, but Teddy’s Dream 2 comes up again here I had a dream in which a lady who shouldn’t be there appeared in the Dachau concentration camp From there, the dream unfolds more and more, and Rachel appears, a dead body appears, and various other things happen, so I’d like to confirm this First of all, the bodies of mother and child in Dachau So the mother is Rachel and the daughter is Rachel They’re both Rachel I had a dream where Rachel gets up and is like, “Why didn’t you help me?” These two Rachels from the Dachau concentration camp were featured So these two Rachels appear as the corpses of a Jewish mother and child I think that having Rachel appear alongside Teddy really expresses the confusion inside him The Rachel that Teddy is chasing is Teddy or Lady Andrew Lady So there’s a part of me that doesn’t know which one Rachel is It means you’re confused Why didn’t you help me? My daughter says, This is the trauma that ladies carry That is the biggest factor I couldn’t help my daughter The trauma of not being able to help his daughter when she wanted it most left Andrew Laeddes with PTSD, which then led to him developing dissociative identity disorder This is a question to ask yourself I could have helped my daughter Why couldn’t I help you? My daughter wanted help If I had paid more attention to my wife and managed her better, it could have been prevented I was preoccupied with work He said that my children died because of my drinking This trauma is what Andrew Reddy is feeling, and that is why he is having these kinds of dreams After that, the scene changes to the Dachau commandant’s office Apparently, there was a lady in the chief’s office The ladies struck a match and said, “We’re friends, right?” and “Don’t hate me.” This is a pretty interesting scene, with Lady Arson, who is supposed to be a complete fantasy, making an appearance The arsonist lady looks just like Teddy said she did She had different eyes and a scar running from her temple to her mouth, but the real arsonist was obviously Dolores, not Lady Gaga Despite this, the fact that the ladies were able to appear properly was due to Teddy’s strong I think it was because I was able to imagine what this lady looked like and I was able to imagine her in a way that had absolutely no connection to Dolores This lady arsonist is sitting in the chair in the commandant’s office at Dachau concentration camp It is connected to the genocide, and that is why I am here Why is the Dachau massacre linked to Dolores’ arson? The one who is connected by association is Teddy himself or Lady Andrew Lady’s main personality Andrew Ladies himself The Dolores arson and other incidents Because they think it’s a kind of genocide Teddy believes that Dolores murdered his daughters Teddy or Andrew is thinking about it So that’s why they’re shown together, as they are associated with the Dachau concentration camp massacre Dolores comes out covered in blood and something like that happens “Ladies are still alive I was saying things like, “He’s here Find him and kill him.” But in this dream, The discovered Rachel appears and plays the role of Dolores Rachel Solander, who was actually a nurse, came on and played the role of Dolores I think it’s particularly striking that Dolores is giving orders to Teddy Dolores is You give a lot of orders to Teddy They give orders like “do this” and “do that.” In this case, the order is “Lady is still alive, so find him and kill him,” but Dolores’s order to “Kill Lady” is… I think it’s something akin to a Thanatos-like suicidal impulse Ladies, Teddy, and Dolores are all Andrew Ladies They’re all the same person All of these are just my dreams and delusions All the characters that appear are DiCaprio I think it’s a bit like having suicidal thoughts But Dolores and Teddy We are definitely in love You keep saying things like “I love you” and “I’ll never let you go” Teddy was definitely in love with Dolores There is this erotic instinct of life I feel a desire to live, or something like that Suicidal thoughts: I feel something like a death drive, but I also feel something like an instinct to live At the same time, this expresses the fact that Andrew Ladies is included within Teddy Teddy is So you’re trying to live for the ladies If I don’t show up, the ladies will die Teddy is currently active in the public eye in order to protect the ladies To achieve this, they inflate their delusions in an attempt to suppress their death drive Ladies, you’re going to die soon Anyway, the ladies are going to die In order to suppress that, Teddy is trying his best not to die This is how Teddy tries to avoid dying in his delusions and dreams So probably In this dream, Teddy and the ladies’ thoughts come out one after another There are a lot of things that can happen, like fires and water coming out This scene shows the ladies’ thoughts, but here we see Teddy’s thoughts So it switches a lot like this, right? In my dreams I go here and there It’s like a lie and reality When these things are replaced, I think you can think of it as an attempt to change personalities This is also written in the book “Billy Milligan” and people with dissociative identity disorder other than Billy Milligan also have this problem Like, this is the image I have in mind I’ve seen a few people say that I think that’s probably the case People with dissociative identity disorder What happens when a personality change occurs in a person with multiple personalities? It’s like there’s a hole in the ground and around it there are all kinds of different personalities sitting around and staring at the hole When you enter the hole, your personality will come out For example, my name is Karuo Suguwa Unlike Karuo Suguwa, Betty and Yocchan Tanaka-kun and Elizabeth There are so many different personalities in my head Now Karuo Suguwa is in the hole The other personalities are waiting around the hole like this But then something came up and Karuo Suguwa came out I want to be in it If you want to come out in public A lot of people are saying that Karuo Suguwa is like, “You go into a hole” and then a personality change happens I think it probably varies from person to person I think the way dissociative identity disorder changes varies greatly from person to person Billy Milligan says that’s how he makes substitutions, and I’ve seen a few people who say they make substitutions in a similar way Well, I haven’t actually seen it I’ve seen it in videos and stuff I think that’s the feeling If so In this dream, water appears, there is a fire, and the memories of various ladies and Teddy’s modified memories alternate, as if they are holding back the ladies who are trying to come out into the open Is that the situation happening in your head? I think it’s okay to think of it that way So if the ladies get in the hole If the main personality, the surface personality, were to emerge, he would die and commit suicide I think Teddy has been struggling to somehow suppress it So Teddy, ladies are thinking The accident left Lady convinced that it was her fault and left her traumatized, but Teddy… It was something that couldn’t be helped It’s like he’s trying to calm Teddy down I think that’s the image I have You don’t have to die I keep saying that it was her fault that Dolores killed the children, that there was nothing she could have done to prevent it, and that it was not your fault Ladies don’t approve of that No, my children died because of me It seems like it was my fault that Dolores ended up like that So it’s all happening in this dream, in this delusion So it’s the ladies and the hospital that are getting in Teddy’s way The plot is set up so that the ladies and the hospital are getting in the way of Teddy Now, here Something strange is happening Because of the typhoon, or rather the disaster, we were able to enter Building C So we decided to go and see for ourselves Of course, this is also part of the play, but Suddenly, Teddy is attacked by a mysterious patient and told about the hydrogen bomb This mysterious patient said: “I don’t want to leave here Who wants to go outside? I can hear a lot of things happening outside Hydrogen bomb tests Do you know what a hydrogen bomb is? A normal explosion goes outwards But the hydrogen bomb explodes on the inside This will create an explosion of incredible power,” he said, holding Teddy down This guy himself exists It actually exists Later, Chuck and the security man took me away…or rather, I should say, I was taken away You go there to get treatment, so this guy actually exists However, it is impossible to say whether the lines this man said are actually spoken or not This story about the hydrogen bomb is an example This is as is What is happening to Teddy or Lady’s mind right now? You say this to express anger and confusion The hydrogen bomb analogy captures Teddy’s feelings so well that it feels like he is the one speaking After this, Teddy beats up the cat guy and is stopped by Chuck and the security guard for the first time here Teddy’s violent side came out to the surface Well, this kind of thing happens Teddy is probably being held in Block C It will look something like this What is the truth behind this hydrogen bomb? Was it really this man who was doing it? Don’t you feel like you were just hallucinating? That’s what I think Shortly after, he comes face to face with George Noyce, who Teddy said was the subject of a psychology experiment George Noyce is a real person The most annoying thing about this person is This George Noyce is a really troublesome character who knows about both the ladies and Teddy He’s a bit of a trickster, or maybe an irregular character This is what George Noyce was talking about “You have two personalities,” he said to Teddy “You have two personalities This hospital is working to bring your personality together So you have to choose between Teddy and the ladies, or you’ll be lobotomized,” George Noyce told Teddy That is, I’m giving away complete spoilers right now Well, the audience and viewers of the movie… So you’ve already noticed something strange about DiCaprio I have dreams, I have delusions, and so on, and I am aware of these strange things I’m aware that there’s something strange about this guy If even a slightly suspicious person appears, I think there are audience members whose minds are already wired to suspect that this is the product of Teddy’s delusions or dreams or something like that As I mentioned earlier, George Noyce He’s clearly an irregular character in the story George Noyce himself is a real person, but the phantom Dolores appears from behind So it’s going to be confusing for the audience George Noyce is there, but the mythical Doloris also exists and appears on the same screen as George Noyce This means that it’s hard to understand what they’re saying It turns out that Teddy had hurt Noyce two weeks ago, and the doctor tells us about it later The reason why he had hurt Noyce two weeks earlier The teacher clearly states You said something like, “It’s because you called me, Teddy, a lady.” Because of this Teddy is the one who is in charge of the dangerous patients There are cases where people are put in Building C Now you know why Teddy gets angry and violent when people call him a lady Teddy exists for ladies Teddy is out in public to protect the ladies from suicide If you call that Teddy a lady, That makes me angry Don’t talk about ladies If the ladies come out because of you, they’ll die If the ladies die, I die too! Do you understand that? That’s why I’m telling you, “Don’t mess with me!” That means you get angry But the reason he gets angry is not clear to those around him, so he is considered a dangerous person Now we move on to the cave scene Rachel Solando II and Teddy ended up meeting in the cave However, just to be clear, she didn’t introduce herself Teddy just said, “Are you Rachel Solander? Are you the real Rachel Solander?” This Rachel 2 is “I didn’t kill my child I haven’t even had a child I am not married either “Before I was a patient, I was a doctor.” I feel like, is that Rachel Solander? But it’s totally different What did he say after that self-introduction? You’re basically saying the same thing as George Noyce Rachel Solander 2 is saying the same thing as George Noyce What I was talking about was that this hospital is conducting research and administering psychotropic drugs They perform a procedure called a lobotomy Like what the Nazis, the Soviet Union and North Korea did We’re doing this mental experiment here too You, Teddy, You are being used by the hospital The clue is in the lighthouse Rachel Solando 2 says This is almost almost It’s similar to what George Noyce said This is Rachel 2 To be honest, I’m not sure if it actually exists Because he’s saying the same thing as George Noyce George Noyce himself exists, but it’s hard to say how much of what George Noyce said was actually what he said Just in this cave Teddy is taking a nap This is the conversation that took place after that nap Teddy said to Rachel: I was like, “Have you seen my guys?” So Rachel 2 is You were like, “You never had any friends to begin with.” Judging from Rachel 2’s response, we can assume that Rachel 2 does not actually exist Because Rachel 2, who had been in the cave the whole time, As for whether I know the details of Teddy’s circumstances, I feel like it’s a bit vague, so it’s possible that he didn’t actually exist Or it’s an auditory hallucination So my conversation with Noyce And the conversation with Rachel 2 here What Teddy is thinking is an auditory hallucination Or what Andrew Reddy thinks He was hallucinating and telling Rachel 2 what he was thinking He had Noyce speak in the same way Same thing happened in Building C I do think that maybe there was a time when the doctor had allowed that patient to speak That’s what happened On the hospital side, There was a time when she stopped putting up with Teddy’s delusions and denied Chuck’s existence The director suddenly said, “You came alone.” Of course, this is also part of the plan At this point, I told Teddy to stop living with his delusions and face reality That means you’ve been planning it from the beginning When Teddy tries to go to the lighthouse, Dolores appears and says, “Get off the island! Don’t go to the lighthouse! Get away now!” But Teddy goes to the lighthouse And that’s when the reveal begins Dolores is It’s like, “Run away!” It’s like, “Don’t go to the lighthouse!” If things continue like this, Teddy or the ladies will Because you will learn a very painful truth If Teddy What could happen if you knew the truth about what really happened to the ladies? First, So what happens is that Teddy’s personality will disappear and only the Lady will remain Teddy is He exists to help the ladies, but once Teddy finds out that the past you’re talking about, the past you know, is all a lie, and the real past is the one the ladies have Maybe Teddy will disappear from this world and only the ladies will remain Teddy realizes that he is lying… If he fully realizes this, a change in personality may occur and Ladies may appear The director is hoping for this, but if only Lady exists and Teddy disappears, there is a high possibility that she will commit suicide That’s why Dolores is telling me not to go Dolores was also created by Andrew Leeds It can be said that it is one personality It’s a little different from a personality, but in Dolores’ case, the ladies created it It’s like a control organ, or something like that As for Teddy, Lady couldn’t bear the reality anymore, she had a mental breakdown, and created Teddy So Dolores was created to help Teddy So it seems that Dolores is trying hard to keep the truth from being discovered by Teddy So this is one One thing that could happen if Teddy finds out the truth Teddy’s personality disappears and only the Lady remains This is the worst possible conclusion So suicide happens Another possibility is that a new personality may emerge Lady created the Teddy personality because she had developed a trauma that made her unable to bear her own life That Teddy is also my own personality When you can no longer live with your past Maybe a new personality will be born to protect Teddy So there is a possibility that a third personality or something like that might emerge So Dolores doesn’t like either possibility It’s like saying, “Don’t go to the lighthouse! Run away!” Well, either way, Teddy goes to the lighthouse Like I won’t be happy So that means Dolores = Ladies = Teddy thinks so So Teddy goes to the lighthouse and finds out the truth The main character wasn’t Teddy, but a man named Andrew Reddy He was a former sheriff who participated in the liberation of the Dachau concentration camp His wife’s name was Dolores She suffered from depression and had a tendency to commit suicide One day, she set fire to her apartment and attempted suicide Seeing his wife like that, Ladies began to turn to alcohol The Ladies family lost their apartment in a fire We moved to a house on the lake But then Dolores killed her three children by drowning them in a lake Andrew, unaware of this, returns home to find that he has no idea what he has done It was the image of his wife and three drowned children Andrew was hospitalized after shooting his wife, who killed their child Andrew couldn’t bear his past so he created another personality called Teddy Teddy came close to merging his personalities before, but was actually reset Andrew has violent tendencies and is a trained ex-military and ex-sheriff, so he will be extremely difficult to subdue Considering the safety of other patients and staff, we decided to consider a lobotomy The director, who is opposed to surgical treatment, decided to resort to extensive psychiatric treatment as a last resort So that was the role-playing therapy that you did today If Andrew’s fantasy comes true, he’ll surely regain his sanity The more you act, the more you will come to terms with the contradictions within yourself and regain your sanity That’s what the director thought So, did Andrew Ladies come to his senses after coming across a contradiction? That was the theme of this article, but what do you all think? Did Andrew Ladies come to his senses after coming across a contradiction? As a result, Suguwa thinks so That’s not the case! That’s what I mean Andrew Ladies or Teddy Daniels? I don’t think I’ve come across any particular contradictions in my delusions or my past Of course, in reflections on the past and in dreams There were a lot of strange things that happened that are hard to describe There’s water even though there’s a fire Mysterious… I have delusions and things like that Well, there were some contradictions I don’t think Teddy was too worried about it, and he dealt with it on his own So there was no particular moment when I came to my senses after coming across a contradiction Last time, we went as far as this, so that means the ladies After this, he regained his original memories and the reason why Teddy’s personality was formed After calmly talking about these things, the personalities were integrated into one, and Teddy was gone, leaving only Andrew Ladies It started to look like this The reason why it seemed like she had a ladylike personality was because of her over-the-top acting I think it would be better to say that he didn’t regain his senses due to a contradiction, but rather that he seemed to have regained his memory due to shock therapy resulting from the shocking revelations from the director and Dr. Shean So it seems like the original memories were restored not because of any contradictions, but because of the shock therapy This is the last line It was the next day or so When I was talking with Professor Shean, DiCaprio… He answers questions as Teddy Daniels, not Andrew Ladies So it seemed like, “Oh, I guess I’ve gone back to the way I was.” So in the end it was no good after all When it seems that a lobotomy is the only option, Teddy says his final words: The movie ends with him asking, “Which would be better? To live as a monster or to die as a good person?” Maybe Teddy has actually regained his memories as Andrew Ladys and is trying to kill himself At the end, I feel that way, but I don’t know which it is That’s how it ends This is a possibility I think there are three One is that the ladies have reverted back to their original Teddy The original Teddy or the temporary Teddy? This is Teddy who came to this island as a sheriff The treatment was unsuccessful as he reverted back to Teddy The first possibility is that this last line was just something muttered without any particular meaning, and the second possibility is that the treatment was successful and Teddy became a lady, but he killed his wife and his three children died After thinking about reality, I came to the conclusion that it would be better for me to die than to live in this world The second possibility is that she deliberately chose to undergo a lobotomy The third possibility is that he makes a decision to help both Lady and Teddy A third personality is born, and the third personality, a new person, is playing the role of Teddy and decides to have a lobotomy These are the three possibilities that come to mind I think there is a good chance that a third, new personality has been born, but the movie doesn’t reveal which one it is I think it’s fine for each viewer to have their own opinion, but the most important thing I can say is What I can say about this video is that the director was I think the experimental treatment, which sought to restore sanity by creating a contradiction, was a failure For a different reason… If he regained his sanity, perhaps he regained his sanity for a different reason I think he has regained his sanity…or maybe his personality has been integrated This concludes Suguwa’s original commentary on Shutter Island Thank you for listening
【動画内で紹介した動画等】
・パプリカ 独自解説 夢とうつつの大傑作！
・地上最大の作戦
https://amzn.to/4aZqaw8
・２４人のビリー・ミリガン
https://amzn.to/4jXbL7q
・ビリー・ミリガンと23の棺
https://amzn.to/3QdqEVx
1954年、連邦保安官テディ・ダニエルズ（レオナルド・ディカプリオ）とチャック・オール（マーク・ラファロ）ら捜査部隊は、ボストン港（英語版）の孤島（シャッターアイランド）にあるアッシュクリフ精神病院を訪れる。この島でレイチェル・ソランドという女性が、「4の法則。67は誰？」（The law of 4. Who is 67?）という謎のメッセージを残して行方不明となった。強制収容されている精神異常犯罪者たちの取り調べを進める中、その病院で行われていたマインドコントロールの事実が明らかとなる。（wikiより）
監督 マーティン・スコセッシ
脚本 レータ・カログリディス
原作 デニス・ルヘイン
製作 マーティン・スコセッシ
ブラッドリー・J・フィッシャー
マイク・メダヴォイ
アーノルド・W・メッサー
製作総指揮 クリス・ブリガム
レータ・カログリディス
デニス・ルヘイン
ジャンニ・ヌナリ
ルイス・フィリップス
出演者 レオナルド・ディカプリオ
マーク・ラファロ
音楽 ロビー・ロバートソン
撮影 ロバート・リチャードソン
編集 セルマ・スクーンメイカー
製作会社 フェニックス・ピクチャーズ
捜査を進めていく中で連邦保安官の2人は、島に謎が多すぎることに不信感を強めていく。
感想 考察 レビュー
守鍬刈雄オリジナルグッツはコチラから
→ https://up-t.jp/info.php?type=user&id=6321ac85c6441
メンバーシップ「守鍬の裏を知る者たち」始動！
・顔出し＆ハミ出し配信。・限定動画・オーディオコメンタリーなどなど裏コンテンツを続々追加！
どうぞよろしく！
《iPhoneでメンバーシップになる方法》
【1】https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCOCIYvBw9MiicB2AIRrPKGA
上記URLをコピーする
【2】Safariを開きURL欄にコピーしたURLを貼りつけて検索しチャンネルのページへ飛ぶ。
【3】ページに飛んだらデスクトップ用webサイトを表示させる。
表示のさせ方は左上の【ぁあ】【AA】をタップ。
iOS12以前の方は下の【共有】をタップ。
【4】チャンネルトップに≪メンバーになる≫が表示されるようになる。
《今回取り上げた作品の配信先》
※2025年2月現在
【U-NEXT】 見放題で配信中
初月31日間無料トライアル実施中！（PR）
登録はこちら→ https://bit.ly/3CtHTMW
【アマプラ】
→https://amzn.to/4hJGIKM
【Netflix】
→ 配信無し
「守鍬刈雄のお暇なら映画でも」が書籍になりました！！
（アプリスタイル刊行）絶賛発売中！
Amazon → https://amzn.to/3tZQboV
Yahoo!ショッピング → https://store.shopping.yahoo.co.jp/appli-style/b0620.html
●サブチャンネル 守鍬刈雄のとらわれないch → https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCoUDVFnJyJWGPdX7euuFu8A
●守鍬刈雄のLINEスタンプ販売中！ → https://line.me/S/sticker/9539489
「スタンプショップ」からクリエイターズスタンプで「守鍬刈雄」または「SUGUWA KARUO」で検索。
●Twitter → https://twitter.com/y7fuwkrscpqp3vh
●TikTok ← https://www.tiktok.com/@suguwakaruo
●リクエスト一覧を確認する → https://suguwa.work/category/request/
●リクエストをする → https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCOCIYvBw9MiicB2AIRrPKGA/community?view_as=subscriber
●配信中動画を確認する → https://suguwa.work/2019/07/11/post-23/
♪映画を暗記科目にしたくない！♪
守鍬刈雄が独自視点でひとつの映画を考察・レビューし、それを解説してたり、あらすじを紙芝居にしたりしてます。
#ShutterIsland #すぐわ #守鍬刈雄 #vtuber